Federal Court of Appeal overturns approval of Northern Gateway
In a two to one decision, the Federal Court of Appeal has overturned the Harper government's approval of the Enbridge Northern Gateway Pipeline, finding that the federal government's consultation process with First Nations on the BC coast that occurred after the NEB decision and the Joint Review Panel Report was inadequate, saying:
We conclude that Canada offered only a brief, hurried and inadequate opportunity in Phase IV—a critical part of Canada’s consultation framework—to exchange and discuss information and to dialogue. The inadequacies—more than just a handful and more than mere imperfections—left entire subjects of central interest to the affected First Nations, sometimes subjects affecting their subsistence and well-being, entirely ignored.
The dissenting judge found that the federal government under Stephen Harper had adequately consulted the First Nations. The split decision means that one of the parties, either the federal government, Enbridge Northern Gateway or the Canadian Association of Petroleum Producers may seek leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada.
Read the decision
Northern Gateway decision (PDF)
Other Media
Globe and Mail
Appeal court overturns Ottawa’s approval of Northern Gateway pipeline
NEB indefinitely suspends any consideration of Northern Gateway – Northwest Coast Energy News
[…] In a letter to John Carruthers, president of Northern Gateway Pipelines, Shery Young, secretary to the Board said that suspension came after the Federal Court of Appeal quashed the permission certificates for the project. […]